Protect Your Cards

Turn your cards into market-ready assets with our PSA Grading and Consignment with the Fanatics Collect program. From professional grading with PSA to streamlined consignment through Fanatics Collect, we make it easy for collectors to authenticate, elevate, and sell with confidence.

Pull It. Grade It. Sell It.

From live break to final payout, our white-glove PSA grading and consignment program makes the process easy, secure, and exciting!

1

Pull Your Card

Hit a card in one of our live breaks and choose to send it through the PSA program.

2

Choose Your Path

Go with PSA grading only, or select grading plus consignment if you want us to handle the sale too.

3

Pick Your Service Level

Place your card in the right PSA tier based on its declared value and your preferred turnaround time.

4

We Handle the Submission

Our team takes care of the setup, service selection, and secure shipment to PSA.

5

PSA Grades Your Card

Your card goes through the PSA grading process and is returned once grading is complete.

6

Move Straight to Consignment

If you choose consignment, we submit your graded card to Fanatics Collect and manage the entire selling process for you.

7

Get Your Card or Get Paid

Keep your newly graded card, or let it sell and receive your payout — all through one trusted partner from start to finish.

PSA grading fees are separate and based on declared value. **pantheon club members receive different benefits and payout percentages**

PSA Card Grading - Service Fees

PSA Service Level Est. Turnaround Max Insured Value PSA Fee WTH Service Fee
Value Plus45 Business Days$500$49.99$15.00
Value Max35 Business Days$1,000$64.99$25.00
Regular25 Business Days$1,500$79.99$25.00
Express15 Business Days$2,500$149.00$25.00
Super Express7 Business Days$5,000$299.00$50.00

Fanatics Collect - Consignment Payments

  • Under $50,000
    110% of final hammer price
  • Above $50,000
    111% of final hammer price
Children with trading cards at a table in a store setting

Why Grade Through WeTheHobby?

Your cards hold memories, milestones, and stories worth protecting. Submitting through WeTheHobby gives you a simple, supportive way to move through the grading process with confidence and ease.

When you submit through WeTheHobby, you get:

  • Professional grading and secure encapsulation
  • Careful intake and handling from a team that truly loves the hobby
  • A smooth, stress-free submission process
  • Friendly communication throughout the journey
  • Peace of mind knowing your collection is in caring hands

We handle every card with care and attention, because we know what it means to you.