WeTheHobby Buyback Program

Sell with confidence. WeTheHobby makes it easy! We take pride in every repack we build, and our Buyback Program gives you a quick, transparent way to turn your hits into instant cash. Fair offers, fast. No stress, no guesswork.

Why Sell Your Card Back?

  • Fair, Transparent Value

    Every card is comped using verified market data from trusted sources. We know the market moves fast, and our system ensures your offer reflects real, up-to-date values.

  • Quick & Easy Process

    Just fill out the form and we'll handle the rest. To ensure smooth processing before shipping, please submit your form within 12 hours of the stream ending. Our operations move fast!

  • Trusted Team

    Our Buyback and Customer Support teams treat every submission with care, making the entire quote-to-cash process simple, professional, and reliable.

  • Guaranteed Floor Protection

    If a card's value drops below its guaranteed floor after your box was opened, we'll still honor the original guaranteed amount.

    How it Works

    Blue check mark icon

    Check Eligibility

    All graded cards pulled from WeTheHobby repacks qualify. If the card was pulled elsewhere, email us at cards@wethehobby.com and we’ll let you know if we can work with it.
    Get In Touch
    Icon of a web browser window with text boxes

    Submit the Form

    Fill out and submit our quick Buyback form to start the process.
    Fill out Form
    Blue dollar sign icon in a circle

    Receive an Offer

    We determine repack value based on real market data from sources like ALT, CardLadder, eBay, and other public auctions giving you a data-backed, fair offer.
    Icon of a hand with a finger pointing to a check mark and an 'X'

    Decide What You Want

    Offers are no-obligation; you’re free to accept or decline. If you decline, we’ll ship your card back to you quickly.
    Icon of money with a dollar sign

    Get Paid

    For card sales up to $25,000, we send payment directly to your PayPal. For larger sales, we issue a secure bank wire, always confirming your preferred method before finalizing.

    FAQs

    Have questions about our Buyback Program? We've got answers.

    Get in Touch
    What cards qualify?

    All graded cards pulled from WeTheHobby repacks qualify for Buyback. If you pulled your card elsewhere, email us at cards@wethehobby.com and we’ll let you know if we can work with it.
    What if I don’t remember what break the card came from?

    No worries! Just give us as much detail as you can (player, set, year, grade, etc.). Our team will help identify it.
    Can I decline the offer?

    Yes. All offers are no-obligation. If you decline, we’ll return your card quickly and securely.
    Do you negotiate on offers?

    We don't typically renegotiate buyback offers, as they're based on verified market data and consistent comping methods. That said, we always want to be fair. If you have recent or relevant market data that you believe supports a different value, our team is happy to take another look and review it with you.
    How do payouts work?

    For cards valued up to $25,000, we pay via PayPal.
    For sales above $25,000, we send a secure bank wire.
    You choose the method before we finalize the sale.
    What does “Final Sale” mean?

    Once you approve the offer via email and payment has been sent, the sale is final. We can’t cancel or reverse transactions after payout because market conditions change quickly and inventory moves fast. We want to keep the process fair, transparent, and consistent for the entire community.
    How long does it take to receive my quote?

    Our Buyback Team typically provides quotes within two business days of receiving your order from our Operations Team. In some cases, turnaround times may vary slightly depending on overall volume or operational processing speeds but we always work to review and return quotes as quickly as possible.
    How long will my order be held for buyback?

    If you've submitted a buyback request, we'll send your quote as soon as it's ready and hold your order while we wait for your response. In most cases, our team will send a follow-up email in case the original message was missed. If we don't receive a response within five business days of sending your quote, your order will be shipped out as normal to keep operations running smoothly.